I usually wouldn't post this but with embarrassment, I will share w you in hopes of others avoiding this / gettint some info.
I have been in the hobby for 6-7 years and while am no expert, I consider myself to be fairly good with fish. I have kept multiple difficult species and generally did well w qt'ing everything to avoid ich by using TTM and before that, hyposalinity with no losses.
Recently, I got it into my brain that I want a large angel and I decided to go with a juvi emperor. I set up 10 gallon qt (they are fairly small so I don't see a need for a larger qt tank. I picked one up from Rainbow pets that was eating Mysis and was about 3 inches. At the same time, I got a flame angel from a buddy who got it at the wholesale. Put both into qt w a plan to do TTM. The emperor swam around, ate the few Mysis I placed in and generally acted normal. I went to work, came back, he was dead w his mouth wide open. No damage, no spots, nothing except death. The flame was breathing very heavily.
I had premade water which I put into a 5 gallon bucket and moved the flame angel there. Figuring I just had an unlucky break I bought another emp and put him into a new qt along w the flame later that evening. He lived about 12-15 hours w the same story as above. I barely feed in the qt to avoid ammonia when first placing fish. He died but the flame was normal at the time, finally dying a few days later (never got him to eat). After doing some research, I decided that I have velvet, most likely from the flame. TTM doesn't work on velvet so it's either copper or chloroquine phosphate. .
I ended up ordering a larger juvi online and that one did not eat anything and is dying as we speak.
To rule out several easy possibilities, I run a small koralia pointed up as well as a bubbler so oxygenation is not an issue. I'm very careful w feeding and have a ammonia badge as well as a cycled foam filter, so that's not an issue either. I clean and dry the tanks between uses. I match the source salinity usually about 1.020. I'm basically at a loss. Either way, I killed more fish in the last 2 weeks than I have in 4 years.
If any of you have suggestions, or have experience w large angels and getting them through qt, please share.
I have been in the hobby for 6-7 years and while am no expert, I consider myself to be fairly good with fish. I have kept multiple difficult species and generally did well w qt'ing everything to avoid ich by using TTM and before that, hyposalinity with no losses.
Recently, I got it into my brain that I want a large angel and I decided to go with a juvi emperor. I set up 10 gallon qt (they are fairly small so I don't see a need for a larger qt tank. I picked one up from Rainbow pets that was eating Mysis and was about 3 inches. At the same time, I got a flame angel from a buddy who got it at the wholesale. Put both into qt w a plan to do TTM. The emperor swam around, ate the few Mysis I placed in and generally acted normal. I went to work, came back, he was dead w his mouth wide open. No damage, no spots, nothing except death. The flame was breathing very heavily.
I had premade water which I put into a 5 gallon bucket and moved the flame angel there. Figuring I just had an unlucky break I bought another emp and put him into a new qt along w the flame later that evening. He lived about 12-15 hours w the same story as above. I barely feed in the qt to avoid ammonia when first placing fish. He died but the flame was normal at the time, finally dying a few days later (never got him to eat). After doing some research, I decided that I have velvet, most likely from the flame. TTM doesn't work on velvet so it's either copper or chloroquine phosphate. .
I ended up ordering a larger juvi online and that one did not eat anything and is dying as we speak.
To rule out several easy possibilities, I run a small koralia pointed up as well as a bubbler so oxygenation is not an issue. I'm very careful w feeding and have a ammonia badge as well as a cycled foam filter, so that's not an issue either. I clean and dry the tanks between uses. I match the source salinity usually about 1.020. I'm basically at a loss. Either way, I killed more fish in the last 2 weeks than I have in 4 years.
If any of you have suggestions, or have experience w large angels and getting them through qt, please share.