FS: Tyree LE Mayan Sun Favia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Feb 6, 2011
Messages
80
Likes
1
Points
0
Location
Santa Barbara
#12
I'm lost... First of all this doesnt look like a favia. What species it is? How are these any different from the wild colonies that are at my lfs?

I guess I should go buy a colony at this price!?
 
Joined
Jan 18, 2009
Messages
2,192
Likes
33
Points
0
Location
Huntington Beach
#13
I'm lost... First of all this doesnt look like a favia. What species it is? How are these any different from the wild colonies that are at my lfs?

I guess I should go buy a colony at this price!?
If you're having trouble Identifying corals try buying "Corals of the World", it should help a LOT! But I would tend to trust Tyree, and every hobbyist who has bought corals from him over the last 10 years, if he has it labeled as a favia, it probably IS!!!
If you're lost, here's the link to Tyree's site to clarify,
http://www.reeffarmers.com/limitedmayansunfavia.htm
 
Joined
Feb 6, 2011
Messages
80
Likes
1
Points
0
Location
Santa Barbara
#17
Lol thnx J. Its definitely one of the nicest favias out there!!
I agree it's nice, but it's not rare. I don't think most places are even able to sell it for $25 a polyp. But I guess you have the tyree version?


Just because Steve put his name on it and called it a LE only means retailers like you and him feel that you have the right to charge insane prices for a specific coral. I could understand that kind of marketing if the item was unique or uncommon. As I stated earlier I have seen other colony come in recently. They look exactly like the frags you sold. That leads me to believe that your selling wild corals that look like the LE. I have no clue where you got yours from, but you never stated the original post so that's why I question it. I also don't think you have the right ID for the coral. It clearly looks nothing like the photos in Verons book. The coloration, polyp shape, and growth are all different. IMO

I'm okay that you want to talk down to me in your own for sale thread; after all I was the one asking questions. I was originally asking what made your frags unique(tyrees version). All that's been offered up are photos of wild colony's and wild freshly cut frags. Also a Veron photo of a Favia. I don't want to point fingers, but it sure seems to me your offering up a wild coral and calling it a tyree because it has the same coloration as the tyree.

Many people do this today, lots of stuff has gained common names this way. Mostly zoas, but lots of lps and sps as well.

I will crack my Veron books and talk to some importers and find out what the "Mayan sun" is being imported as and maybe that will lend an ID for the coral. Maybe your right after all. I have my doubts as it doesnt look to me like ID you posted.
 

5ft24

New member
Joined
Jun 14, 2010
Messages
1,248
Likes
10
Points
0
Location
Bellingham
#18
Dude, did you even go to the reeffarmers site and look at it with the description?
Steve Tyree went to coral gazers after the frag swap at davelinks, and if it wasn't a Tyree LE, he would have said something and made them change it...
wow... 10 posts and you are the coral expert...
 
Joined
Feb 6, 2011
Messages
80
Likes
1
Points
0
Location
Santa Barbara
#19
Yes, I read every word on the page and looked at all the photos. I am 100% sure of what the coral looked like when it came out of the ocean and was fragged by tyree and WTF. I am unsure of how this vendor got his coral and sold it. That's all I'm asking. As long as a proper ID if someone knows it. Sorry if I don't post on your board enough to ask a question about lineage.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Top