Checked out AoA today and it was just what I was looking for. Great selection and the staff is even better. I will make it to some of the meetings there as well. Happy to join the community here, and thanks for the reference!
I swung by Strictly Fish while I was out and they seemed alright as well. Just as Subzero said: good selection of fish, corals were a little more limited, and prices were comparable, if not even a little more expensive for fishies compared to AoA. I will probably go to both stores with a preference for AoA.