I will have to check out Wet Pets. I did not realize they were right in my backyard
Treasures of the Sea - they know their stuff but I agree with everyone. Their prices are much higher than other stores.
Mystic Reef - Excellent frag selection. I usually deal with Jeremy, and sometimes you have to play haggle games with them.
Salties - This guy runs a tight ship! All tanks are pristine and fish are very fat every time I go there. He only has two or three tanks with corals but they are all beautiful and good size. He buys/sells used equipment too.
Global Aquatics - They are in Ontario, so quite a drive for me. This is a very large store. Freshwater, saltwater, corals, hardware, tanks, etc. The owner can sometimes be a bit grumpy (maybe he just does not like me?), but Robert can hook you up.