I spent way too much time on this :/
So here is my take on the Supporter/Sponsor/Moderator/Administrator badges. I figured if I did one then I would do them all so that there is consistency between them all. They follow the same design, but each have their own color and a different fish in the large bubble. I liked the bubbles and fish on the old logo, so I took the position of an upgrade rather than a redo.
Let me know what you think or if there are any suggestions.
Thanks!
Here are the 150 x 100 pixel badges:
The background is the same color as the panel they will display on(in dark reef), so it will look pretty seamless.
Here is a larger image of the badges: